U.P. nursing homes rated
Posted: 12.18.2008 at 5:19 PM

Seven get five stars, two get only one star.

Photo

UPPER PENINSULA -- You could hear some cheering...and grumbling...from nursing home operators across the Upper Peninsula Thursday.

That's because the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services released its ratings of nursing homes nationwide.  Thirty-two facilties were listed in the U.P.

Seven of them were awarded five stars--the highest rating--and two were given only one star--the lowest rating.

The ratings are based on state inspections, staffing levels, and quality measures, such as how many residents come down with pressure scores.

Although many advocates for the elderly applaud the rating system, critics say the ratings can sometimes be too subjective and rely too much on self-reporting.  Federal officials say the rankings should put the nursing homes on a path to improvement because they know family members will think twice before sending someone to a one-star home.

Listed below, by county, are the 32 U.P. nursing homes and their overall rating:

Alger County

  • Tendercare (Munising) 4 stars

Baraga County

  • Baraga County Memorial Hospital (L'Anse) 5 stars
  • Bayside Village (L'Anse) 4 stars

Chippewa County

  • Chippewa County Mem. Hospital (Sault Ste. Marie) 4 stars
  • Tendercare (Sault Ste. Marie) 1 star

Delta County

  • Bishop NOA (Escanaba) 4 stars
  • Christian Park Health Care Center (Escanaba) 3 stars
  • Christian Park Village (Escanaba) 5 stars

Dickinson County

  • Freeman (Kingsford) 4 stars
  • Hyland (Iron Mountain) 4 stars
  • Manorcare (Kingsford) 5 stars

Gogebic County

  • Gogebic Medical Care (Wakefield) 5 stars
  • Josephson (Ironwood) 2 stars
  • Westgate (Ironwood) 4 stars

Houghton County

  • Cypress Manor (Hancock) 3 stars
  • Houghton County Med. Care (Hancock) 4 stars
  • Our Lady of Mercy (Hubbell) 4 stars
  • Portagepointe (Hancock) 5 stars

Iron County

  • Iron County Medical Care (Crystal Falls) 4 stars
  • Iron River Care (Iron River) 3 stars

Luce County

  • Helen Newberry Joy Hospital (Newberry) 4 stars

Mackinac County

  • Mackinac Straits Long Term Care (St. Ignace) 4 stars

Marquette County

  • Eastwood (Negaunee) 4 stars
  • Marquette County Medical Care (Ishpeming) 4 stars
  • Mather (Ishpeming) 1 star
  • Norlite (Marquette) 5 stars

Menominee County

  • Menominee Care (Menominee) 2 stars
  • Pinecrest (Powers) 3 stars
  • Roubal (Stephenson) 4 stars

Ontonagon County

  • Aspirus Ontonagon Hospital (Ontonagon) 5 stars
  • Maple Manor (Ontonagon) 4 stars

Schoolcraft County

  • Schoolcraft Medical Care (Manistique) 4 stars
Get a full description of each facility's review.