Fact Finder: Road Repair Concerns Watch Video Read Comments
ADVERTISEMENT
Check This Out!

checkthisoutnewhome

yoopertubehome 

Photo

Why U.S. 31 is bumpier now than before being resurfaced.

By Diana Fairbanks
Tuesday, November 03, 2009 at 12:57 p.m.

Read more: Local, State, Economy, U.S. 31, Repairs, Road, Mdot, Elmers, Fact Finder, Diana Fairbanks

These days everyone is keeping a close eye on how they spend their money, and how the government is spending its money.

In a previous Fact Finder Report, we told you about a road construction project in Interlochen in Grand Traverse County. Well, the project is complete, but some drivers are saying the road is worse now than it was before.

Why, what's being done about it, and who's paying for it?

The answers in tonight's Fact Finder Report.

Eric Abramczyk works in Interlochen and drives U.S. 31 nearly everyday. And for weeks while crews resurfaced the road as part of an $800,000 preventative maintenance project, Eric, like many other drivers had to sit and wait.

Diana asks, "How long would you have to wait?"

Driver Eric Abramczyk replies, "Too long usually, 20 minutes to a half hour."

But even though the road wasn't too bad to begin with, many drivers were willing to wait, thinking it would be even better when it was finished. The problem is, crews are long gone, and the road isn't smoother now.

Abramcyzk says, "I think they could have used the money for a much better cause rather than a road that's still bumpy."

And a lot of viewers echo those concerns.

While it's hard to see on camera, it's easy to feel when you're driving this newly resurfaced stretch of U.S. 31: lots of little bumps dotting the drive adding up to a big annoyance.

I contacted the Michigan Department of Transportation and Elmer's the contractor who completed project for answers.

The first question, what is it?

Elmer's Marketing Director Tonya Wildfong says, "It's tack. The bumps on the road are not actually bumps in the road."

Tack is basically the glue that binds the old asphalt to the new asphalt. But Wildfong says it can build up on the work truck's tires, and can come off in globs, that lead to a bumpy drive for motorists. And while it's not rare, it is more evident in a project of this size.

Wildfong says "it happens quite a lot when you have long paving projects, large areas that are open and it had to be with traffic control on a large project like this one."

And cleaning it up isn't complicated. A machine basically scrapes off the globs of tack.

Wildfong says, "We do it throughout the project and there's usually a clean up that we do to close out the project but unfortunately the weather hasn't cooperated for us to do that."

Our unusually rainy fall has caused Elmer's to postpone the final clean up. But it is included in the cost of the project, so scraping up those globs of tack won't cost the state any additional money. And Elmer's hopes to have it complete sooner rather than later.

Wildfong says, "We're hoping to get out there soon, for sure before November 15th. That's our closeout date, as soon as possible weather permitting."

So what do you think about this? Do you have something you'd like us to look into for you? Leave your comments below.

SPONSORED CONTENT
13 Comments on this Story
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them; they are not reflective of the views or opinions of Barrington Broadcasting, TV6, its directors or employees. If you believe a comment violates the Barrington Terms of Use, please report it here.

The 15th has come and gone

Posted by April Arnott, Interlochen - Friday, November 20, 2009 at 3:47 p.m.

The road still has not been cleaned up and the weather has been fine for almost 2 weeks. I would like to know why it was not taken care of by now? I think a follow up interview is needed since it is now November 20th.

No Improvement as of November 13, 2009

Posted by Joan Dewey, Interlochen - Saturday, November 14, 2009 at 10:49 a.m.

Interesting that Elmer's representative mentioned the weather as the culprit for the delay in resolving the inept repaving of US 31 between Interlochen and Chums Corners. I couldn't imagine more beautiful weather than what we experienced this past week (Nov 9-13th) and yet, the road remained untouched. The project completion date of Nov 15th is right around the corner. Makes you wonder if Elmer's and MDOT are hoping this issue just goes away with no additional effort on their part.

Joe public....

Posted by used to work for a general contractor, UP - Friday, November 06, 2009 at 8:41 a.m.

I don't know the specifics of the job, however there is no way an $800,000 contract was handed over to any one company. Everything in the construction industry is bid, unless if it is a private job, and even then it is rare to not have numbers take control of the situation. Low bidder gets the work, period.

If they are forced to go back and fix inadequate work after the completion date has come and gone they are forced to pay "liquidated damages", an amount per day, usually in the $500-$1000 per day range until the road/project passes inspection, so it is a hard hit on projects that are bid tight. One would think if that happens often enough and the profit from jobs is being eaten up in liquidated damages, sooner or later a company will simply go under.

The problem here in the end sounds like the road shouldn't have passed inspection. Maybe they have an "in" with someone higher up on the chain of command to be able to pass inspections if their work is truly that shotty, however, no $800,000 job was handed over to a company.

I agree with R.C.

Posted by Tom Deasy, T.C. - Wednesday, November 04, 2009 at 6:55 p.m.

While Elmer's workmanship quality may not be held in high regard, one must admire their skill at making excuses.

Just A Little Ticked

Posted by Returning To The 70's, UP Here - Wednesday, November 04, 2009 at 11:13 a.m.

I am still appalled at the fact that downstate is getting good roads redone when they are reverting us back to the pre-70's style of gravel!! Why isn't some of this wasted (YES, WASTED I DID NOT STUTTER) money put to the use of at least giving us one coat of blacktop on our crappy roads? At least keep patching the patches!! Reverting 40 years or more does not cut it in todays society with all the extra taxes we are paying now versus what we paid in the 70's. Upper Michigan has nearly 1/3 of Michigans land mass, why are we not allowed enough money to at least keep the roads we have in better shape than gravel? There is ONE decent road throughout this entire county. ONE! THAT IS DISGUSTING WITH THE AMOUNT OF TAXES PAID BY ALL THE RESIDENTS OF THIS COUNTY!! And now people are voting to increase taxes again for road repairs. We already pay for road repairs!! Yet somehow the funding has never made it to our roads! WHY? Is it the idiots downstate that don't know the U.P. is a part of Michigan too, or is it the little pigs we have in our local govt.?? Either way...our roads are still being reverted to the pre-70's era and if that is the case...then we should be paying pre-70's tax rates too!! I'm really fed up with paying, paying, paying and getting roads reverted to gravel for the payoff while downstate is having perfectly good roads, made (apparently) worse!!

BUMPS IN THE ROAD

Posted by robert sudekum, traverse city - Wednesday, November 04, 2009 at 9:30 a.m.

I did not mind the little spots of tack, but i drive through interlochen every day and west of there the road is bad enough to bounce my truck like my tires are out of balance. i have not had that experience on other new roads. So i think useing the excuse that because it is a big road we cant fix it is wrong.
if you were haveing a house built and they did not do it the right way you would have them fix it. just because elmers does a lot of roads cookie cutter style
and just wants to power them out like a burger joint does not mean that they should not have to fix it. "if your burger was made the wrong way you would expect them to fix it same thing here" it just the right thing to do

BUMPS IN THE ROAD

Posted by robert sudekum, traverse city - Wednesday, November 04, 2009 at 9:23 a.m.

I did not mind the little spots of tack, but i drive through interlochen every day and west of there the road is bad enough to bounce my truck like my tires are out of balance. i have not had that experience on other new roads. S

Road work

Posted by Francis Geebae, Traverse City - Wednesday, November 04, 2009 at 8:11 a.m.

I've found Elmers to be exceptional in their work, road work included. They're a study in efficiency, their drivers are generally safe and polite, and they do exceptional cleanup work after jobs. This sounds like a special case where they can't get in to do final cleanup. I've worked jobs with a lot of crews, and I'd pick Elmers any day over many local outfits.

shabby work

Posted by joe public, kingsley - Tuesday, November 03, 2009 at 11:22 p.m.

i just cant believe that elmers is still getting work doing roads considering the poor quality of work they do for starters they didnt do the road right in the first place they never do and to blame it on tack? well thats not it its because they didn`t do it right in the first place if you look at all the roads elmers done recently compared to other companies in the area you can see that elmers quality just isnt as good and shame on those people who keep giving them contracts for work just becuase they have been in the area forever and donate alot to the local comunities what we need is roads done right grind them up level and mix the grindings in and make them wider so there are bike and moped room along the sides not just a quick skim coat over the old so i gues the moral of this is simple dont hire elmers

Money hungry people

Posted by R C, Traverse City - Tuesday, November 03, 2009 at 9:41 p.m.

Elmer's Pockets are bigger then their brains!!! Their quality of work has gone down hill. I hope they read these comments and get a clue! They are the highest priced and their quality of work is no better then anyone else.

BUMPS

Posted by Ditkas Mustache, KINGSLEY - Tuesday, November 03, 2009 at 8:23 p.m.

" The bumps in the road aren't actually bumps. " Well, what can you say about that load of tripe.

Shame

Posted by Vicki Wade, Interlochen - Tuesday, November 03, 2009 at 7:47 p.m.

Shame on you, Elmers! You should be embarrassed with the quality of this road. Please make it right, not just scraping, but fix the dips in the road, too. There are scraps left on the turn onto 31 from 37 and at the turn at Interlochen corners. Shame on you!!!

"It's tack."

Posted by Jackie Lautner, Interlochen - Tuesday, November 03, 2009 at 6:41 p.m.

There may be "tack" on the road but that is not the problem. The first time I rode down that new stretch of road with my husband, I said to him, "is there something wrong with the tires on the cat?" He said, "no, it is the road." It was like we were driving on little ripples that bounced our car. I asked others that drive that road if they noticed teh ripples. They all said, "yes. If you look closely in spots, you can actually see the little waves in the newly surfaced blacktop. It was not my car. It is the road. It was definately a poorly done job

News
ADVERTISEMENT

PopularCommented


CONSUMER INFO